Evolutionary Creation — Chapter 4 — The Ancient Science in the Bible
Just over a year ago, at the Ancient Hebrew Poetry blog, John Hobbins observed that “Walton’s arguments are receiving a lot of attention, perhaps especially from those who espouse evolutionary creationism (Mike Beidler, for example).” Apparently, Hobbins is concerned about this because he believes that not only does Genesis 1 describe the assignment of functions to things, but that it also concerns the material creation of things. In the aforementioned post’s comments, Professor of Hebrew Studies and Ancient Near Eastern Studies Alan Lenzi also took me to task for “taking Walton’s view as the typical ANE scholar’s view. And that’s simply not the case.” Interesting, I thought. I’ll have to check into this a little bit more. It didn’t take long to begin seriously reconsidering my stance on this, and chapter 4 of Evolutionary Creation has (in lieu of Walton’s forthcoming monograph on Genesis 1, which was announced in his response to Hobbins) put me solidly in the camp of Hobbins and Lenzi.
Considering all of the other non-Genesis 1 references to “ancient science” throughout the Scriptures that Lamoureux presents, it also makes sense to interpret Genesis 1 this fashion. Did the ancients not really consider, as Walton suggests, how the material world came into existence? My suspicion is that Walton, despite the evidence, is forced to interpret Genesis 1 as a “non-material” creation account (albeit wrapped up in a genre that mimics ancient Mesopotamian and Egyptian temple dedication texts; see this post) because his commitment to a certain brand of biblical inerrancy requires him to do so. In essence, Walton’s brand of inerrancy posits that, even in matters of science, the Bible is without error. (Walton also seeks to anchor the events and personalities of Genesis 2-11 solidly in history.) By reinterpreting Genesis 1 in such a fashion that it does not touch on the creation of material things, he bypasses the “more correct” and “more natural” interpretation for one that is in more harmony with his hermeneutic.
So what was this evidence that made me shift camps from Walton to Hobbins/Lenzi? The first line of evidence was the voluminous amount of biblical references to a 3-tiered universe. Of course, this fact is nothing new to Walton. In fact, he agrees wholeheartedly that Genesis 1’s cosmology contains the three tiers of heaven, earth, and the underworld. But Walton wants to have his cake and eat it too. Because this cosmology doesn’t comport with physical reality (which Walton will readily agree), he believes Genesis 1 cannot possibly be speaking of material creation. However, this ancient cosmology isn’t just restricted to Genesis 1; it extends into the New Testament as well (e.g., Phil 2:10), and it is much more pervasive than Walton either lets on or recognizes. Thus, Walton’s hermeneutic appears to stop at Genesis 2 and fails to work beyond this point.
The Evidence of the Bible’s Ancient Science
Many Christians would claim that descriptions of a 3-tiered universe fall into the category of “phenomenological language,” that is, language that describes appearance from a certain, fixed perspective rather than reality—for example, sunset and sunrise. It is true that we use terms like sunset and sunrise as phenomenological descriptions of the earth’s rotation on its axis, but that is only because our interpretation of Scripture is informed by the fact (taught to us in school and proven with every launch of a satellite or manned space mission) that we do not live in a geocentric universe. Prior to heliocentrism becoming mainstream, a vast majority of ancients took this so-called phenomenological language as scientific descriptions of reality. If this is so, then the Bible is, in fact, scientifically inaccurate. However, this does not bother Lamoureux one bit:
Passages in the Bible referring to the physical world feature both a Message of Faith and an incidental ancient science. According to this interpretive principle, biblical inerrancy and infallibility rest in the Divine Theology, and not in statements referring to nature. Qualifying ancient science as ‘incidental’ does not imply that it is unimportant. The science in Scripture is vital for transporting spiritual truths. It acts as a vessel similar to a cup that delivers “living waters” (John 4:10). However, the word “incidental“ carries meanings of “that which happens to be alongside” and “happening in connection with something more important.“ In other words, the ancient science in Scripture is “alongside“ the “more important“ Message of Faith. (p. 110; emphasis in original)
Lamoureux then proceeds to discuss numerous examples of “ancient geology” that bears absolutely no resemblance to physical reality:
- The earth is immovable (1 Chr 16:30; Ps 93:1; Ps 96:10)
- The earth is set on foundations (Job 38:4-6; Ps 75:3; Ps 104:5)
- The earth is surrounded by water (Gen 1:2; Job 26:10; Ps 24:2; Prov 8:27)
- The earth is circular, not spherical (Ps 19:4; Ps 104:2; Is 40:22)
- The earth has ends, or edges (Isa 41:8-9; Dan 4:12; Matt 12:42)
- The earth has an underside and an underworld (Num 16:31-33; Prov 5:5; Isa 14:15; Matt 11:23; Luke 10:15; Eph 4:9-10; Phil 2:10; Rev 5:13; Rev 20:14)
- The earth is flat (Dan 4:11; Matt 4:8)
Of course, these descriptions are not unique to the Bible; they are, in fact, similar if not identical to descriptions of the cosmos in other ANE cultures as depicted, for example, in ancient Babylonian maps.Lamoureux next tackles “ancient astronomy,” in Walton-like fashion, discussing the likes of the daily movement of the sun, the firmament (the apparently firm, blue dome that covers the earth), the waters above the the firmament, the foundations and ends of heaven (including its various levels), and the placement of the sun, moon, and stars in the firmament itself. Like Walton, Lamoureux appeals to the original languages to bolster his arguments quite convincingly. (An eschatological futurist, Lamoureux has some interesting views on how he believes eschatological events might play out in the physical realm, but it is enough to say that Lamoureux believes that “divine judgmental action is filtered through ancient astronomical categories.” I’ll tackle this in a post later down the road.)
And if the Bible’s geology and astronomy weren’t ancient enough, Lamoureux adds “ancient biology” to the mix, proving that the Bible possesses ancient conceptions of taxonomy, botany, human reproduction, and the causes behind suffering, physical/mental disabilities, and disease:
- Bats categorized as birds (Lev 11:13-19)
- Cud-chewing rabbits (Lev 11:5-6)
- Mustard seeds declared (indirectly) smaller than orchid seeds (Mark 4:30-32)
- Spontaneous generation (Gen 1:11, 20, 24; Mark 4:26-29)
- The “one-seed” theory (Heb 7:9-10) of human reproduction, which blames the woman for being barren (Gen 11:30; Gen 25:21; Gen 29:31; Gen 30:22-23; Luke 1:7, 36; Heb 11:11).
- (Lamoureux takes an interesting view on the causes of various physical and/or mental maladies, to wit, that some of these illnesses attributed to demons actually have a natural, non-demonic cause. I’m not quite prepared to comment on this view.)
Conclusion
If the examples of ancient science in Scripture were relegated to only a few instances, one might be able to successfully argue against Lamoureux (and Walton, to a certain extent). However, it is clear to me that, in matters of science, the Bible does not concord with physical reality in a great number of cases. What are we to do with this fact? Lamoureux suggests that
it is necessary for modern readers of God’s Word to separate the Message of Faith from the incidental ancient science, and not to conflate these together. According to the Message-Incident Principle, inerrancy and infallibility rest in the spiritual truths of Scripture instead of its views on the structure and operation of the physical world. (pp. 146-147; emphasis in original)
I’d say this is an excellent place to start for the Christian struggling to reconcile the Bible with science. It is certainly counterintuitive at first to recognize and respect the incidental ancient science, but with practice it becomes natural to separate the “wheat” (theological truth) from the “chaff” (ancient science). It may also help to begin thinking of the Bible as somewhat incarnational, that is, both human and divine, much like (although not identical to) Jesus Christ. Is it really so hard to conceive of the Bible’s purpose as the transportation of divine truth in a fallible vessel? Wasn’t this also the case with the incarnation of the second person of the Triune God, Jesus Christ, who brought ultimate truth via the humiliating experience of becoming a physically fallible human being possessing an intellectually-limited human mind?
Good post Mike. It’s funny that I’ve never seen a conflict between Walton’s and Lamoureux’s positions on Genesis. I’m curious if they themselves percieve eachother to be “rivals” in that sense.
Perhaps I have a bias that assumes concordism between the two, but I’ve always understood DL as saying “the bible only contains ancient science (whether structure, function, or formational history).” — and I’ve always understood JW as saying “Genesis focuses primarily on the act of God organizing the primordial chaos into functions, AND THEREFORE DOES NOT INTRODUCE ANY NEW COSMIC STRUCTURES that were not already known at the time.”
So while Genesis obviously address cosmic structure such as the firmament, the waters, etc… (does Walton really say that it doesn’t?), it’s focus is clearly on the establishment of function since it only recycles the existing structures and creates nothing new.
Walton’s brand of inerrancy posits that, even in matters of science, the Bible is without errorI had the same question Gordon has. I do agree that Walton seems to be perhaps unduly driven to defend Genesis from charge of error, but as you mention in the post, he articulately describes the shortcoming of the ANE cosmology, biology, etc. seen in Scripture, so if the quote above were fully accurate, I’d be highly surprised.
As I understand it, Walton’s position is that God doesn’t seek to reveal something in Scripture and fall flat on His face in doing so. If there’s bad science, it could only be because that wasn’t the subject of the revelation. The inaccurate old world science we find in Scripture was only a vehicle for revelation of inerrant truths (such as, chiefly, God’s authorship and command of Creation).
Mayhaps I’m reading him incorrectly, and I don’t deny that Walton has a more traditional view of inerrancy than you, Lamoureux, and I. But ANE scholarship doesn’t really seem to disagree with Walton that the ANE saw function more as a consequence of purpose rather than of structure. Inasmuch as the Genesis account of creation addresses the formation of physical structures of the cosmos, it was perhaps unavoidable given their necessity as functionaries. Walton’s seminal point, I think, remains. But again, maybe I’m misreading you or him on this.
Gordon & Steve,
I would really encourage you guys to read John Hobbins' post “Does Genesis 1 describe the creation of things or the assignment of functions to things? A Response to John Walton.” “The obvious answer,” Hobbins writes, “is both. John Walton, however, argues that Genesis 1 is concerned only with the assignment of functions to things. He suggests that the Hebrew verb ברא, translated in the past as ‘create,’ with the object of the thing created following, means instead to ‘establish a function, assign a role,’ with the object of the thing whose function and role have been established following.”
Although Walton is right on the money regarding the importance of assigning purpose and function, he overemphasizes this feature at the expense of the meaning of the word “create.” Of course, Walton, in his response to Hobbins asked, “So, why can’t Genesis 1 be both functional and material? Of course it CAN be both, but each one would have to be demonstrated, not assumed.” Okay, fine. But notice what Walton writes a little later on: “Day 2 has a potentially material component, but nobody believes that a solid dome actually exists.” Walton betrays his bias here. The ancients DID believe that a solid dome actually existed! I may be misreading Walton here, but it seems to me he doesn’t want the Hebrews to be wrong about this and thus ignores the full import of what ברא means.
Walton also responds that “he likened Genesis 1 to a cosmic temple dedication account. What would the creation of a temple be? The material phase would only be staging. Even when the material phase was entirely complete, it would still not be a temple. The temple is created in the dedication ceremony when it is made functional.” I see a false dichotomy being posed here: either Genesis 1 is speaking of material creative acts or it’s speaking of assigning function. It’s both. I agree with Walton that the description of the creation is not literal and presented as a temple dedication text, but the subject of the text is the creation of literal objects. That is to say, the ancients likely did not believe the cosmos to have been created in such a literal fashion, but it did concern the creation of said structures.
I will, of course, purchase Walton’s Eisenbrauns-published monograph when it becomes available and I don’t intend to be dogmatic about this. It’s just that when I read Walton after reading Lamoureux, the tensions underlying the text of Walton’s Genesis commentary are all the more apparent.
So I read as much as Amazon would allow me of Walton’s new book, and the point of chapter 1 (Genesis Contains Ancient Cosmology) seems to be that Genesis only contains ancient science. Of course, the title of chapter 2 is “Ancient Cosmology is Function Oriented” – which I think is true as long as you don’t take that to mean “function only”. However, if Walton does go on to say that structure was totally 100% inconsequential, then that would indeed seem to be overstating the case. But I would be surprised if Walton did that.
If Walton really did say that “nobody really believed that a solid dome existed” I can sort of see his point. In fact, I argued a similar thing in BTF. Think about it like this: supposedly, the sky was a solid dome – specifically, like a steel bowl that has been hammered out (indeed the word firmament means to spread or hammer out). And supposedly there were waters atop this structure that explain why the sky, from earth, looks like the ocean does from a cruising altitude of 30,000 ft. The waters atop the dome were thought to explain the source of percipitation and the appearence of the sky as a distant ocean. And openings in the solid dome provided passage of the heavenly bodies in and out of the sky each morning/evening.
A modern person would immediately cry foul because how the heck could you see the upper waters if they were blocked by a sold metal structure? Or how did the openings at the horizon work if there were actually waters on the other side? As rediculous as this sounds to us, I don’t believe, and I would assume that neither does Walton, that this obvious material violation would have raised any red flags in the ancient Near-Eastern mind. And why not? Because structure took a back set to function.
Remember, for the Mesopotamian, the land was literally the lower half of Tiamat’s carcus, and the sky was the other half. For the Egyptian, the land was Geb and the sky was Nut, and the air was Shu, holding up the sky. Did they really believe, in a material sense, that the very land that they walked upon was the re-fasioned body of a deceased god? Did the Egyptians really think that the air was structually the god Shu? Or did the Mesopotamians really think that the Tigris and Euphrates flowed from the eye-sockets of Timat’s skull?
Perhaps they did, but I still don’t think its wrong to say that material structure took a back seat to functional issues. That’s all I’ve ever understood Walton’s position on Genesis 1 to be.
Perhaps when I get around to reading Hobbins’ post in its entirety, his complaint will become more clear. But this is probably nothing more than an in-house turf war over who will emerge as the authoritative voice on Ancient Near-Eastern interpretations of Genesis than it is about anything truly substantive (understanding, of course, that “everything” is substantive when it falls into your field of academic expertise :)).
I am not really sure what the fuss is about here. DL and I have had discussions at length and there is not much about the ANE that we disagree on.
As to whether my view of Scripture is more conservative than another person’s, it may well be but I don’t know what that has to do with anything. It is always my intention to try to read the text the way that the ancient author and audience would have read it. I think that is what we are all interested in whatever faith aspects we bring to what it says.
This is why I do not believe that there is any new science being revealed in the text–because we do not FIND any new science in the text. I don’t differentiate Genesis 1-2 from anything else on that count.
When I said that nobody believes that a solid dome actually exists, I was talking about in modern times. Of course some people believed that in ancient times and through much of history.
I am generally pretty consistent about saying that in the ancient world they were much more interested in the functional aspects as over the material aspects. This does not mean that they had no awareness of the material. Of course they refer to material aspects of cosmic geography (seas, raqia, etc.) but the question that I address is whether Gen 1 is intended to be an ACCOUNT of material origins, and my conclusion is that it is not. Instead, as an account of functional origins, it is very much like the ANE creation accounts.
Much of this will hopefully be clarified in my IVP book, Lost World of Genesis One due out June 12, though the Eisenbrauns book will have more detail (still hoping for the fall, but I haven’t gotten edited manuscript back yet).
Please don’t read the post on Hobbins blog as representing the full and authoritative statement of my position. It was written off the top of my head to try to answer a couple of questions that were floating around (as this one is), not to build the entire case and explain everything. The full treatment of my position is presented in my publications, not on any blog.
I was particularly concerned with Lenzi’s comments which I believed misrepresented my position and misunderstood what I was doing in my book on Ancient Near Eastern Thought.
I hope this clarifies a few things. Perhaps in a few weeks my book will clarify a few more.
John H. Walton
Just to clarify, neither Denis Lamoureux nor I would be content with leaving the impression that we are in wide agreement across the board. But on understanding of the ancient world and the ancient Near Eastern literature, I am not aware of significant differences
Gordon,
Thanks for the head’s up on Amazon’s “sneak preview” of Walton’s new book. I, too, read as much as Amazon allowed and, from what I read, my criticisms of Walton’s views appear to be legitimate, although not necessarily correct. 😉
the title of chapter 2 is “Ancient Cosmology is Function Oriented” – which I think is true as long as you don’t take that to mean “function only”. However, if Walton does go on to say that structure was totally 100% inconsequential, then that would indeed seem to be overstating the case. But I would be surprised if Walton did that.In Walton’s new book, he writes, “The view offered of Genesis 1 recognizes that it was never intended to be an account of material origins. … if the Bible does not offer an account [emphasis in original] of material origins we are free to consider contemporary explanations of origins on their own merits, as long as God is seen as ultimately responsible” (p. 133).
Note two things that Walton says (and implies) here: (1) Genesis is NOT an account of material origins, and (2) because it is not, we are free to consider evolution as a means of God’s creative activity. Thus, it is not logical to assume that, according to Walton, if Genesis IS an account of material origins, then we are NOT free to consider evolution as God’s creative process?
If we admit that Genesis 1 actually describes the Hebrews’ conception of how the cosmos came into being (parallels to temple dedication texts notwithstanding!), this does nothing to the authority of Scripture, for there are plenty of other instances in the Old and New testaments in which ancient science rears its head. If Walton doesn’t mind that Jesus declared the mustard seed the smallest seed in the world (ignoring the much smaller orchid seed), then it shouldn’t matter to him that Genesis 1 reflects ancient scientific categories. Again, if these other instances of ancient science do nothing to diminish the Bible’s authority in our eyes, why should an admission of Genesis 1 as a material creation account make a bit of difference to us? It shoudn’t. Now, it is entirely possible that Walton’s view of the authority of Scripture hasn’t driven his understanding of Genesis 1 and that his “function/purpose trumps structure” thesis is what he has come to understand independently of his faith, but it sure seems that way.
On a related note, is it Walton’s intention to completely rid ANE scholarship of the “creation myth” genre? Does he wish to see the Enuma Elish be labeled a “function myth” or “purpose myth”?
… obvious material violation would have raised any red flags in the ancient Near-Eastern mind. And why not? Because structure took a back seat to function.Granted, function and purpose may be the primary concern of Genesis 1, but just because structure takes a “back seat” doesn’t mean that structure still isn’t in the car. Function and purpose underscores the material.
Remember, for the Mesopotamian, the land was literally the lower half of Tiamat’s carcass, and the sky was the other half. For the Egyptian, the land was Geb and the sky was Nut, and the air was Shu, holding up the sky. Did they really believe, in a material sense, that the very land that they walked upon was the re-fashioned body of a deceased god? Did the Egyptians really think that the air was structurally the god Shu? Or did the Mesopotamians really think that the Tigris and Euphrates flowed from the eye-sockets of Tiamat’s skull?That’s my point. I agree that the ancients didn’t believe, in a material sense, that the land was a dead god’s corpse, but metaphysically it was. (Echoes of transubstantiation, anyone?) Regardless of the metaphysical overtones of ANE creation myths that focused on purpose and function, there is still the material element that is sadly overlooked.
(continued)
this is probably nothing more than an in-house turf war over who will emerge as the authoritative voice on Ancient Near-Eastern interpretations of Genesis than it is about anything truly substantiveVery possible, but I still see that there is a fundamental difference between Lamoureux’s view of ANE and Walton’s view of ANE.
Dr. Walton,
I am honored and thrilled to have you interact with me here! Regardless of my critiques of your views, I hold you and your work in very high esteem. This blog exists as a direct result of discovering and reading your commentary on Genesis several years ago. It opened up an entirely new world to me and I am eternally grateful. In fact, your books (along with Gordon Glover’s book) are the first things I recommend to those who are struggling with understanding the place of Genesis 1 in their journey to reconcile their faith with science. I am looking forward to reading The Lost World of Genesis One as well as your Eisenbrauns monograph of Genesis 1. Consider both purchased. =)
I am not really sure what the fuss is about here. DL and I have had discussions at length and there is not much about the ANE that we disagree on.All due respect, Dr. Walton, I would beg to differ. The material vs. function/purpose debate is a significant disagreement. You even declare as much on p. 133 of your new book, where you write, “The view offered of Genesis 1 recognizes that it was never intended to be an account of material origins. … if the Bible does not offer an account [emphasis in original] of material origins we are free to consider contemporary explanations of origins on their own merits, as long as God is seen as ultimately responsible.” Lamoureux goes beyond your thesis that Genesis 1 speaks only to function and purpose and posits that material creation is ALSO discussed here.
It is always my intention to try to read the text the way that the ancient author and audience would have read it.I certainly don’t intend to besmirch your academic reputation, Dr. Walton, but I think we can agree that, as fallen human beings, it is extremely difficult to rid ourselves of all bias. This includes me, to be sure. If I may ask, how would your view of the authority of Scripture change if your research strongly suggested a primarily material component to Genesis 1? Is it at all possible that pressures from Wheaton could be wielding influence, possibly unconsciously, on the results of your research? How free are you to explore things? If you were to accept theistic evolution as your cosmology of choice, would your job be at risk?
To be fair, from reading the preview of your new book, your views on the historicity of Adam and Eve do appear to have “evolved” somewhat. Even before I became an evolutionist, I noticed a considerable amount of tension in your Genesis commentary. While you unwrapped the mythical underpinnings of Adam & Eve and the Garden of Eden, you still attempted to anchor the events of the narrative in history. Now, a number of years later, you opine that the NT authors “regularly treat Adam and Eve in archetypal [rather than prototypal] terms” (p. 71), instead of necessarily historical personalities. This is a significant shift. But how sure are you that the NT authors are treating them as archetypal? What if Jesus and Paul actually believed Adam and Eve to be real historical personalities? Does that affect the truthfulness (and authority) of Scripture in your eyes?
(continued)
This is why I do not believe that there is any new science being revealed in the text–because we do not FIND any new science in the text. I don’t differentiate Genesis 1-2 from anything else on that count.I don’t quite follow you on this point. What do you mean by “new science”?
When I said that nobody believes that a solid dome actually exists, I was talking about in modern times.My humble apologies for misunderstanding what you wrote.
the question that I address is whether Gen 1 is intended to be an ACCOUNT of material origins, and my conclusion is that it is not. Instead, as an account of functional origins, it is very much like the ANE creation accounts.Are there any other ANE scholars who are of one mind with you on this?
Please don’t read the post on Hobbins blog as representing the full and authoritative statement of my position.Understood.
Again, thanks for posting your response on my blog. Feel free to return anytime.
Mike,
Off-topic to the rest of this post, but on the subject of Ch 4, I wonder: If God’s message in using ANE principles was to establish himself as Creator and sustainer, how does that fit into today’s science? By that, I mean, the “science” of ancient times were beliefs built on untested, non-empirical methods. Lamoureux says that God used this incidental vessel to deliver his Message of Faith. In effect, the acceptance of supernatural beliefs was an opportune time for God to reveal that he was the supreme supernatural force. (Or that monotheism was the obvious ultimate stance for believers in supernatural forces).
On page 110, Lamoureux says, “[I]nstead of confusing or distracting the biblical writers and their readers with (our) modern scientific concepts, God descended to their level and employed the science-of-the-day.”
Okay. That might have been fine for the ancients, but why does God leave in place the writings and science of ANE history? Why doesn’t he descend to our level today and explain things in modern scientific terms and prevent Christians from splintering and arguing with scientists who are meticulous about discovering truth? What a wonderful vessel science would have been — that we should dream and speculate, develop methods to test our ideas, develop ethical protocols, that we would have accountability, and develop a moral system to demand and deliver truth.
In human history, 5000 years from Abraham to the empirical method (perhaps less 1000 years if the church hadn’t introduced the dark ages), is not a long time. Yet, God chose to deliver his message to the ANEs. Why then? Why not the Chinese or the Americans, or some other population of the time if it had to be then?
What was so special about this vessel — these sheepherders around Egypt around 3000 BC — that God chose to use it/them? How do you think it affected and still affects the theology that has evolved?
(You can reply in different posts, if you like).
Hi Tom,
Lots of good questions. In one you ask: "If God's message in using ANE principles was to establish himself as Creator and sustainer, how does that fit into today's science?"
I think what we have to do is separate the Message of Faith (God creator & sustainer) from its incidental ancient scientific vessel, and then apply it to whatever is scientifically true. Thus, we can see God as the creator and sustainer of the evolutionary process. And if evolutionary theory crashes, well bring on the next scientific theory of origins, and use it as a vessel to carry these eternal and inerrant theological truths.
Best,
Denis
Tom,
If God's message in using ANE principles was to establish himself as Creator and sustainer, how does that fit into today's science? … why does God leave in place the writings and science of ANE history? Why doesn't he descend to our level today and explain things in modern scientific terms and prevent Christians from splintering and arguing with scientists who are meticulous about discovering truth?
I honestly don't have an answer to that question, Tom. It's one that I haven't yet given much thought, although it is on the backburner of my mind.
I will say this: if God were to accommodate to our current level of scientific knowledge, in another century (if not sooner) He would have to repeat His accommodating acts. But I don't think that's necessary. For millennia, thoughtful theologians have been able to (as Denis puts it) single out the Bible's Message of Faith and find contemporary application. This, I believe, is the more important task at hand, and one for which our intellect is well-suited, regardless of the "science of the day." (Granted, there are times when the Message of Faith is obscured by the Incidental Vessel, but I think that this happens less often than we realize.)
What a wonderful vessel science would have been — that we should dream and speculate, develop methods to test our ideas, develop ethical protocols, that we would have accountability, and develop a moral system to demand and deliver truth.
What's not to say we can't do this, or that we aren't doing this currently?
In human history, 5000 years from Abraham to the empirical method (perhaps less 1000 years if the church hadn't introduced the dark ages), is not a long time. Yet, God chose to deliver his message to the ANEs. Why then? Why not the Chinese or the Americans, or some other population of the time if it had to be then?
I would venture to say that it was a result of divine timing. In which area and era would the delivered message impact the most people in the shortest amount of time?
What was so special about this vessel — these sheepherders around Egypt around 3000 BC — that God chose to use it/them? How do you think it affected and still affects the theology that has evolved?
Wow. Give me some time on that last question. 😉
Great questions, all, Tom! Keep thinking along those lines and keep us theist types on our toes!
Pingback: Seeing Evolution Through New Covenant Eyes | Rethinking the αlpha and Ωmega
I couldn’t refrain from commenting. Exceptionally well written!
fildena 100 online india
viagra 88
trazodone online prescription
buy tretinoin cream online australia
buy lasix online australia
viagra medication
albuterol cost in uk levitra for sale online tadalafil tablets uk ordering sildenafil online without prescription
clomid pills buy online
doxycycline order
viagra 100mg tablet price in india
plaquenil 100
buy vermox in usa
feldene gel price uk
over the counter lyrica
wellbutrin 500mg
diclofenac 1.5
elimite drug 500mg erythromycin lisinopril 5 mg buy online baclofen over the counter australia buy fildena 150 rx augmentin generic for lopressor
nolvadex from canada
generic zithromax over the counter lasix tablets uk phenergan tablets otc atenolol 25 mg tablet buspar 7.5 cheapest buspar dapoxetine cream indocin pill
dapoxetine tablet price in india
zyban otc where to buy over the counter where to buy cytotec online cheapest flomax avodart for sale online finasteride online pharmacy india tetracycline no prescription 120mg propranolol
toradol 10mg cost
misoprostol price in india wellbutrin 250mg amoxicillin 875 pills
metformin 500 mg tablet buy online
bactrim order online
azithromycin 500 mg mexico
clomid tablets price in south africa
aurogra 100mg tablets buy toradol online legitimate mexican pharmacy online generic zestoretic zestoretic 20 25 mg ivermectin 400 mg brands
sumycin
10 mg doxycycline
dapoxetine purchase
inderal 10mg cost propecia cost comparison
lipitor 10mg price usa
buy motilium usa
buy cheap tizanidine online buspar coupon
priligy price
where can i buy amoxocillin
medicine azithromycin nolvadex tablet
antibiotic augmentin
retino 05 cream finasteride usa singulair purchase online 120 mg furosemide clindamycin phosphate topical accutane medicine
mail order pharmacy no prescription albendazole otc buspar 60 mg
atenolol 50 mg india
buy propecia us
atarax otc
provigil cost
augmentin 87
order zoloft uk
furosemide 40 mg cost
avodart capsules 0.5 mg
propranolol er lyrica 150 mg coupon baclofen brand name in usa propecia purchase online canada
canadapharmacyonline
metformin online purchase uk
buying bactrim online chloroquine generic name zestoretic 20 25 mg vermox 500mg tablet price
kamagra oral jelly cvs can you buy metformin zovirax cold sores generic albendazole online cleocin ovules clonidine sleep dapoxetine pills for sale phenergan tablets
lyrica 200 mg
paxil gas
zestoretic 10 12.5
buy lyrica 75 mg online
buy generic hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg
avodart no prescription
clindamycin otc
best online pharmacy nolvadex
motilium 10mg tab
modafinil cost toradol tabs avana 50 sildalis online albendazole usa phenergan otc nolvadex price in south africa retino 05
prednisone brand name australia prednisone 50 mg cheapest buspar
online pharmacy ed
azithromycin 250 mg tablet price
legitimate online pharmacy
buy nolvadex online australia strattera 100 mg buying nexium online bactrim uk pharmacy paxil 300 mg
misoprostol 100 mcg
global pharmacy
buspar pill azithromycin order online tamoxifen 20 mg tablet online pharmacy in germany dapoxetine 30mg 1mg lasix 40 mg pill propranolol 80 mg tablet atarax online uk
furosemide generic
buy cheap nolvadex online
clonidine gel
generic propecia finasteride
low cost online pharmacy
avodart online pharmacy
furosemide online canada
buy aurogra 100 flomax price comparison erythromycin drug digoxin for chf
over the counter hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg
pharmacy online 365 prednisolone 25 mg australia price lyrica pills 150 mg
inderal buy online usa how much is metformin 500 mg
buy dapoxetine uk
canadianpharmacyworld medicine azithromycin 500 mg
purchase hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg
zestoretic 20-25 mg
reddit canadian pharmacy list of online pharmacies legal online pharmacy coupon code best online pharmacy reddit best canadian online pharmacy
erythromycin for sale
furosemide 20 mg tablets
digoxin online purchase
online pet pharmacy
tetracycline tablets 500mg
best price metformin can i buy paroxetine over the counter phenergan tablets 25mg uk cozaar brand name gabapentin 31 canadian pharmacy coupon code
noroxin pill
erythromycin 500mg tablet cost tretinoin cream cost in india albuterol in mexico erythromycin 4 gel synthroid 88 mcg cost
lasix online no prescription
propecia costs canada
can i buy accutane online
tizanidine 4 mg capsule
hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg tablet
how to get toradol finasteride 1mg for sale digoxin 0.25 mg cost of hydrochlorothiazide 25mg generic bupropion xl erythromycin generic cost
cheapest online pharmacy india bupropion sr pills online pharmacy store buy prednisolone erythromycin without prescription order propranolol online
buy atarax online uk buy tetracycline capsules furosemide cost price avodart 0.5 mg tab azithromycin antibiotic sumycin 500 mg erythromycin 5 g
flomax 40 mg
singulair otc buspar in canada lyrica 75 mg tablet price in india gabapentin capsules 400mg buspar medicine
azithromycin pills for sale stromectol price in india buy erythromycin cream online toradol headache atarax hydrochloride buy lyrica canada usa pharmacy online aurogra 100 uk
propecia generic 1mg
buy phenergan 10mg
dapoxetine tablets for sale avodart cost australia avodart without prescription buy propecia uk zanaflex online flomax kidney stone tamoxifen india zithromax buy cheap
cost of lisinopril in mexico
digoxin drug
how to buy modafinil uk
buspar price canada
motilium tablet
neurontin online usa
order avodart online inderal 20 mg cost price of toradol
buy zyban generic
buy fluconazole
propranolol metoprolol zanaflex 8 mg tizanidine caps atarax tablet 10 mg
generic bupropion 300mg
prednisolone 1
dexamethasone cream otc
buspar buy online
10 mg paroxetine
where can i buy azithromycin pills
buy robaxin online
medicine albendazole buspar online pharmacy predisone with no presciption generic clindamycin how to get tamoxifen zovirax cream online dexamethasone 20 mg tablet tamoxifen cost canada
purchase nolvadex uk
ivermectin 0.08%
retino 0.25 cream price
levitra buy
where to buy hydrochlorothiazide
generic phenergan
levitra 50mg tablets
triamterene hctz 37.5 motilium price singapore generic buspar tablet
can you buy baclofen over the counter purchase albendazole toradol 10mg cost retino 05
12.5 mg phenergan
effexor 110.5 mg
where can you buy valtrex
ciprofloxacin 500 mg coupon ivermectin cost lasix 10 mg daily diclofenac brand name in usa buy desyrel online
avodart price uk
bactrim cream
cheap clopidogrel
flomax australia
erythromycin prescription online
lyrica 150 mg price in india cipro 500mg dosage zithromax 500 tablet generic cipralex india modafinil drug american online pharmacy generic furosemide 20 mg
desyrel drug
buy provigil online without prescription
furosemide without a prescription
best mail order pharmacy canada
lasix price uk
where can i get cheap flomax
azithromycin doxycycline
buy diclofenac without prescription
pharmacy acyclovir
discount pharmacy trusted online pharmacy legit non prescription pharmacies online pharmacy drop shipping online pharmacy europe trusted tablets coupon code pharmacy discount card
zofran 8mg coupon
compare plavix prices
neurontin drug
estrace 2mg cost
accutane pharmacy online
flomax capsule
clopidogrel over the counter
lopressor hct
ivermectin new zealand tadacip 20 mg price in india cheap suhagra
can i buy retin a over the counter in canada
strattera capsules 40 mg cheap cymbalta 60 mg celebrex 2018 aurogra 200 diclofenac best price canadian pharmacy drugs online can i buy acyclovir over the counter uk
buy lyrica online
robaxin rx buy online augmentin tablet singulair.com buy azithromycin 250 mg without prescription 900mg lyrica modafinil 300mg
azithromycin 2 pills
propranolol 1 mg cialis 300mg buy modafinil in us flomax generic best price
rate canadian pharmacies buy zoloft how to get provigil in usa
tamoxifen citrate nolvadex for sale how to get fluoxetine cost of cialis 20mg in canada
northern pharmacy tetracycline tablets 250mg zithromax generic cheap singulair generic 400 mg prozac bactrim forte aurogra
Dirty dancer Abella Danger shakes her incredible booty and strips to heels centerfold babe pornstar teen brunette Abella
Danger Danny Mountain Abella Danger Cumshot European Jessica Drake Brazer Stockings Table Mia
Ryder Julesjordan Hotandmean Scott Nails Stockings Whippedass Bondage Clothed Karlee Grey Babe Outdoor Tiny Tits Masturbation.
avodart discount
lopressor 50 mg daily
strattera 25 mg capsule price
reliable canadian pharmacy trust pharmacy reputable online pharmacy uk bitcoin pharmacy online promo code for canadian pharmacy meds
price of doxycycline 100mg
azithromycin tablets otc
where to buy modafinil uk
azithromycin 500mg tablets for sale
otc toradol neurontin 800 mg capsules cipro
where can i get misoprostol
happy family store
trazodone price cheap accutane for sale flomax pills
lyrica without rx tretinoin cream canadian pharmacy tretinoin lowest price propranolol cost uk renova tretinoin cream 0.02 purchase
levitra tablet online in india seroquel 300 strattera 40mg tadacip 40 acyclovir 49 order modafinil uk
flomax generic price plavix cost india cipro 500 mg buy albuterol inhaler neurontin 400 mg price
generic zofran 4mg
celebrex online
budesonide capsule brand name how much is plavix medication buy female cialis
cheap budesonide
acyclovir cream brand name
medication zestoretic
buy estrace cream cheap
buy cipro no rx
ampicillin for sale online
zofran 24mg where to buy prednisolone
lyrica 75 mg price in india
buy disulfiram canada
accutane pharmacy prices
is there a generic abilify buy toradol pills online misoprostol otc neurontin price australia
zoloft prescription cost
online pharmacy pain
furosemide tabs 20mg
canada pharmacy not requiring prescription
provigil online purchase tadacip 20 canada azithromycin 500mg 800 mg lyrica cost of albuterol tablets furosemide brand name in india accutane pharmacy buy cipro 500mg
strattera uk
erythromycin purchase
accutane 20 mg price
orlistat 120 mg india mexican online mail order pharmacy tetracycline sumycin singulair prescription coupon online pharmacy pain relief strattera online tadacip 5mg online how much is zofran 8 mg
rx fluoxetine
legit pharmacy websites
generic tretinoin 05 cream
tretinoin 1.0 for sale
azithromycin 500 mg tablet 1mg
where to get cheap valtrex
nolvadex-d
canadian discount pharmacy
happy family canadian pharmacy
buy zofran 8 mg cafergot 1 100 mg tretinoin gel usp 0.1 buy zoloft canada
family rx
cheap fluoxetine
abilify cost canada
buy orlistat online cheap uk
seroquel in canada
buy robaxin canada
can you buy azithromycin over the counter canada
diclofenac india toradol allergy effexor 450 mg
prozac 10mg capsule
canadian pharmacy viagra
suhagra 100mg online
azithromycin 250 1mg
silagra without prescription
silagra without prescription
furosemide 20 mg where to buy
prozac 5 mg
levitra tablets price in india accutane medicine online order zofran online buy strattera paypal buying zoloft in canada zovirax without a rx where can i buy generic zithromax
how much is accutane cost
celebrex canada over the counter
inderal 10 mg tablet nolvadex 10mg price in india robaxin 1000 avodart 0.4 mg nexium price uk
where to buy voltaren azithromycin online sale suhagra 25 mg prozac 60 express scripts com pharmacies
trazodone 150 mg pill
tadacip 5mg price
reliable rx pharmacy
fluoxetine 40 mg discount price for cialis daily use effexor 37.5 mg inderal buy online levaquin buy online azithromycin 250 mg price
zithromax 500 tablet amoxicillin 50 mg seroquel 50 mg modafinil united states cafergot 1mg 100mg buy fluoxetine no prescription online azithromycin cream voltaren 50mg price
amoxil 875
synthroid tab 112 mcg
zoloft mexico
best price for lexapro generic
cafergot purchase azithromycin
buy dapoxetine uk online
toradol 10mg price
500 mg robaxin
how to get zoloft without a prescription
accutane uk
prednisolone online uk
inderal 80
can you buy strattera online
225 mg lyrica tadacip for sale uk propranolol buy usa ivermectin buy
canadapharmacyonline com
buy strattera online canada
modafinil prescription online
where can i buy zovirax
cialis online singapore
accutane cheapest price
tretinoin prescription online canada
global pharmacy
discount pharmacy mexico
where can you get diflucan over the counter
can you buy zithromax over the counter in mexico
strattera prices 100 mg
aurogra 200
best online pharmacy usa
suhagra price
ordering cafegot
can you buy zofran over the counter in canada
buy tadalafil 10mg buy zithromax in usa albuterol australia
canadian pharmacy 1 internet online drugstore
buy provigil
which online pharmacy is reliable silagra price in india rx pharmacy online 24 how much does cipralex cost estrace 0.5 g
online drugs valtrex tetracycline 100 mg
where to get tamoxifen buy cialis online india effexor 187.5 mg ventolin usa cost of antabuse uk order tadacip 20 mg albuterol inhaler for sale
prescription drug plavix
overseas online pharmacy
voltaren 1.16
cafergot
best online pet pharmacy
cafergot 1 100 mg
canadianpharmacymeds
price of lyrica 75 mg in india
0.05 retin a misoprostol pills online paxil 20 mg price best generic levitra nexium medication cost vermox tablets price bupropion online
voltaren gel for sale in usa
cheapest pharmacy to fill prescriptions with insurance buy azithromycin 250mg online generic cafergot ivermectin prescription 1400 mg seroquel
online pharmacy discount code 2018
azithromycin generic cost india trazodone 59 mg otc tretinoin gel fluoxetine best price xenical 120 mg buy online india singulair tablets online
buy celebrex
mexican online mail order pharmacy
lyrica 25mg capsule
gabapentin uk buy
prozac generic brand
where to buy zithromax over the counter
cost of generic synthroid
robaxin medicine diflucan generic australia cost of prednisolone tablets where to buy azithromycin 250 mg buy priligy in australia
retin-a cream 0.05 diflucan 200 mg capsules
where can you get robaxin
azithromycin 500mg lowest price online
accutane 40 mg price in india gabapentin 1000mg
rx pharmacy online 24
lyrica medicine price
bactrim ds 800
cost of ivermectin pill
how much is azithromycin 1g
tretinoin uk prescription
noroxin 500 mg over the counter singulair 10mg tablets accutane 120 mg modafinil india online buy prednisolone online
best canadian online pharmacy zithromax 1000mg tetracycline 500 mg levitra 2019 coupon how to get azithromycin 1g how much is retin a 1 can you buy diflucan over the counter in australia
singulair 5 mg tablet
strattera generic online pharmacy quick delivery tretinoin canada otc bactrim 800 mg coupon cafegot zofran medicine buy levitra online without prescription drug robaxin
acyclovir 400 mg price in india acyclovir order online buy aurogra 100 azithromycin us valtrex capsules where to buy zofran online provigil brand name
diclofenac 100 mg
list of online pharmacies
reputable indian pharmacies
rx robaxin
50 mg accutane
gabapentin drug
azithromycin tablets canada
acyclovir 400 mg cost
non prescription medicine pharmacy
finasteride usa
30 mg buspar nexium 5mg motilium purchase online albuterol inhalers for sale
doxycycline 100mg tablets buy ivermectin for humans australia antabuse cost in us where can i buy gabapentin online synthroid 60 mg estrace 0.01 cream generic buy azithromycin 1000 mg
stromectol uk
zofran 8 mg
tadacip 20 mg
ivermectin buy canada lexapro prescription coupon
buy tamoxifen canada
onlinecanadianpharmacy 24
lisinopril 2.5 mg
strattera prescription drug
neurontin 400 mg capsules order prednisolone generic strattera online erythromycin gel price order modafinil online celebrex 200mg uk generic seroquel xr
erythromycin cap 250mg
can i buy cymbalta in mexico
strattera prices 100 mg buy celebrex online canada desyrel sleeping pill tretinoin 05 azithromycin tabs aurogra 100 zofran
buy seroquel online cheap
ciprofloxacin 700 mg
best no prescription pharmacy
vpxl molnupiravir capsule
where can you buy acyclovir
seroquel for depression
where can you buy zofran over the counter
happy family canadian pharmaceuticals online
price of celebrex 100mg tretinoin cream usp 0.1 canadian mail order pharmacy stromectol 0.1 how to get zofran over the counter cafergot brand name levitra 20mg price australia aurogra 100 uk
zovirax 400 tablet price prednisolone 5mg prices generic vardenafil india seroquel for anxiety and depression generic accutane brands celebrex price lyrica 75 mg generic
pharmacy online shopping usa
voltaren price
ciprofloxacin generic
tretinoin 0.5 cream uk
tadacip cost voltaren gel coupon canada abilify cheapest robaxin online canada buy generic levaquin toradol 10mg pills canadian pharmacy 24 com how much is cipro
buy terramycin uk
cheapest accutane prices
canada pharmacy 24h
zovirax buy ivermectin tablets seroquel depression buy zithromax online fast shipping celebrex 100mg price usa lyrica 300 mg capsule robaxin 114
xenical medication
tadacip 20 mg canada
legitimate online pharmacy uk
finasteride 1mg best price modafinil best price elimite cream price in india estrace cream ingredients
can you buy azithromycin over the counter in usa
lasix 40 cipro cream estrace online pharmacy order lyrica toradol pill 10mg accutane online pharmacy abilify 10mg
rx pharmacy no prescription
bactrim ds 800-160
international online pharmacy buy generic accutane uk
neurontin capsule 400 mg
stromectol otc
accutane tablets
stromectol order online
zofran 8mg tablets
amoxicillin 625mg
buying viagra without a prescription
albuterol rx price
where can you buy propecia
dexamethasone sale
url lisinopril hctz prescription
fluoxetine 30 mg uk
can you buy clomid over the counter us where to buy cialis in australia buy amitriptyline 50 mg uk accutane medication canadian pharmacy in canada can you buy albuterol
lisinopril 5
doxycycline 40 mg coupon
viagra for women uk
affordable pharmacy
finasteride no prescription albuterol drug buy albuterol from mexico drug fluoxetine tretinoin 20 mg capsule
glucophage medicine
can you buy metformin
can i buy cymbalta in mexico reputable online pharmacy no prescription
northwest pharmacy canada
buy albuterol online no prescription
clomid for sale online cheap
albuterol capsules tretinoin 0.5 australia how to buy acyclovir cream synthroid 150 mg coupon ventolin hfa
med pharmacy
buying amoxicillin in mexico order lyrica online canada pharmacy shop antabuse pill can you buy diflucan without a prescription
trazodone 100mg capsules
amitriptyline 20 mg
purchase celebrex online ivermectin drug buy furosemide tablets diflucan canada prescription order augmentin online synthroid 100 mcg from canada
270 mcg albuterol
200 mg accutane
lexapro 5mg
buy lexapro
canadian pharmacy meds
cheap allbuterol
safe reliable canadian pharmacy
disulfiram tablets 2500 mg metformin mail order pharmacy no prescription online otc pharmacy
lasix 40 mg daily
metformin script cost
synthroid no prescription
buy clomid tablets uk
prozac online prescription
online viagra from india
ventolin inhaler without prescription
dexamethasone tablets canada
dexamethasone 0.75 mg tablet
canadian pharmacy cafergot
metformin
how to get zoloft without a prescription
stromectol order
lisinopril 20 25 mg
gabapentin 40 mg
buy celebrex cheap
ventolin 2mg tablet
amoxicillin 500mg capsule cost
buy lisinopril 10 mg tablet
rate canadian pharmacies augmentin 500 mg generic zoloft 50 mg price in india doxycycline brand name cost of metformin in us buy lyrica 150mg
disulfiram brand in india can you buy retin a in europe
retin a gel over the counter
where can i buy metformin 500 mg
how to order propecia online 1.25 albuterol diflucan online cheap non prescription medicine pharmacy cialis india generic combivent aerosol
retin a tretinoin discount viagra uk
disulfiram tablets propecia minoxidil cialis pill cost lexapro 20 mg tablet cheap viagra for sale retin a best price
zoloft tablets in india
antibiotic azithromycin
6 mg dexamethasone buy propecia india propecia 1mg pill zanaflex for back pain cafergot medication generic order retin a from mexico fluoxetine hcl 20mg rx pharmacy online 24
generic zanaflex no prescription
120 mg lasix daily
cheap generic lexapro
purchase tetracycline online
albuterol cost canada generic propecia uk ventolin buy azithromycin from india
buy augmentin tab online no prescription how to get lyrica amitriptyline pills how much is zithromax clomid 25 mg daily buy viagra australia
cost of lyrica medication
cafergot 1mg
lexapro price australia
medication finasteride 5mg
where can i buy clomid without a prescription
azithromycin 10 pills
canadian discount pharmacy
buy metformin no prescription
accutane 40 mg price in india
how to get lexapro prescription
women cialis metformin average cost propecia 0.25 mg
cymbalta 2017
buy lexapro online no prescription
retin a cream singapore lyrica 2.0 zithromax canada
amoxicillin 375 mg price
strattera buy online no prescription
medication cymbalta 60 mg
zoloft 100mg best price
tretinoin retin a cialis pills uk propecia india buy albuterol tablets price price of cymbalta australia lisinopril 1.25 how to get propecia online retin a cream singapore
canada pharmacy online legit
prednisolone 40 mg
generic zoloft 200 mg
average cost of zoloft
12 mg zanaflex
best price for lyrica
112 mcg synthroid price lyrica 25mg capsule celebrex non prescription accutane 40 mg price lexapro 20 buy doxycycline from canada diflucan order tizanidine 4 mg price
best canadian pharmacy no prescription
medication diflucan
where can i buy cafergot
online pharmacy in turkey
where to buy propecia singapore
cheap cymbalta
sky pharmacy
amitriptyline buy online cheap straterra clomid price uk antabuse no prescroption online pharmacy products where to buy lasix diflucan pills online sildenafil 150 mg
augmentin amoxicillin
dexona medicine price
lasix tablets for sale
cipralex coupons
generic viagra tablets best retin a diflucan tablet
antabuse tablets 200mg
lisinopril 5 mg tablet price northwest pharmacy canada canada pharmacy online legit zanaflex over the counter where can you get doxycycline ventolin hfa price zoloft 37.5 mg
propecia online australia acyclovir 400 mg terramycin for dogs ivermectin lice celebrex 200 mg for sale
diflucan 1 pill
doxycycline hyclate 100mg price
gabapentin medicine
lisinopril cost
lasix canada pharmacy
azithromycin otc in us
zanaflex 5mg price
clomid prescription cost uk
vardenafil 10 mg
reputable online pharmacy no prescription
order prednisone
cymbalta capsule 40 mg
amitriptyline over the counter usa
viagra buy usa
usa pharmacy online
mail order pharmacy
austria pharmacy online
accutane online order buy doxycycline uk canadian pharmacy 365
glucophage tablets for sale
proventil albuterol
buy retin a online europe
metformin 850 mg price in india
azithromycin 250 mg 1mg
cheap antabuse
azithromycin for sale online
lyrica cheapest price
buy metformin from india
provigil prescription cost
buy disulfiram india
buy prendisalone on line uk
retin a online mexico online pharmacy dubai cheap albuterol no prescription price generic lexapro furosemide 80 tablet accutane 30 mg price
can i purchase cymbalta in canada
prices for metformin 500 mg
ivermectin syrup
where to buy zithromax over the counter
levitracanada.com glucophage cheap accutane price in south africa india viagra can i buy diflucan over the counter in canada amitriptyline gel
buy zestoretic online accutane singapore cost
trazodone 50 mg daily
dexamethasone 4 mg tablet online strattera prescription cost purchase retin a micro generic finasteride online
diflucan 150 mg capsule
metformin tablets 800mg
no rx pharmacy
cheap metformin
glucophage discount
canada pharmacy glucophage
tizanidine 2mg pill doxycycline 40 mg capsules brand name lexapro discount
lyrica 100 tadalafil price
zestril 2.5 mg
doxycycline 100mg price in india
tretinoin 1.0
cialis discount prices online
accutane for sale online uk
prednisolone for sale online uk
amitriptyline for sale
ivermectin 400 mg brands
strattera price in canada
buy lisinopril 10 mg
metformin hcl 1000 mg order albuterol from canada ventolin hfa 90 mcg compare propecia prices
lyrica without rx
antabuse buy canada
best tretinoin cream brand
pharmacy order online
gabapentin 1200 mg
accutane prescription australia
cost of cialis daily use
where can i get metformin in south africa
offshore pharmacy no prescription
cymbalta duloxetine hcl
brand dexamethasone
dexamethasone 0.25 mg tablet
cost of strattera without insurance
generic propecia cheap
finasteride 5mg coupon
dexona 4mg tablet price
synthroid best price
how much is celebrex
tretinoin mexico
zestril 10
purchase zoloft synthroid 100 mg cost online pharmacy 365 pills
cafergot tablet
secure medical online pharmacy citalopram 15 mg tablet generic lyrica 2018 elavil tablets uk
lasix 10 mg tablet price
dexamethasone otc
how much is a zoloft prescription
buy lasix online paypal order lisinopril without a prescription buy antabuse australia buying lyrica in mexico tadalafil 40mg elavil anxiety cost of lyrica 150 mg generic zithromax
cymbalta price without insurance
lisinopril 10mg tablet furosemide 20 mg pill
synthroid 112 mcg cost
rx pharmacy
trazodone australia
generic cialis 5mg daily
gabapentin mexico buy online diflucan
prednisone from india
tadalafil 10 mg online amoxicillin 500mg price synthroid 88 mcg price lyrica cost in india dexona tablet price in india acyclovir australia internet pharmacy manitoba
online pharmacy drop shipping
www canadapharmacy com
purchase elavil
clomid tablets for sale
buy metformin 1000 furosemide otc ventolin 200 mg cost of propecia in india strattera 80 mg cost order metformin online
where to buy acyclovir cream over the counter
dexamethasone 500 mg tablet
metformin 20 mg
zoloft brand coupon
amoxicillin 500mg capsule price in india
endep 100mg
buy lexapro 10mg zoloft online no prescription
gabapentin brand name in usa
antabuse
azithromycin tablets online without prescription usa
can you buy augmentin over the counter
lasix online canada where to buy propecia in australia best retin a cream australia reputable indian online pharmacy buy trazodone online uk
levitra for sale cheap
antabuse uk buy
can i buy dexamethasone over the counter
amitriptyline 15 mg
buy zoloft without prescription
tretinoin cream without prescription
can i buy azithromycin over the counter in us
average cost of lasix
prozac brand best price
doxycycline hyclate 100 mg cap
furosemide 12.5 retin a gel canadian pharmacy antabuse buy online australia good online mexican pharmacy diflucan brand name 300mg best online foreign pharmacies disulfiram for sale
www pharmacyonline
stromectol covid fluoxetine 20 mg capsule trimox without prescription order levitra online in usa
generic levitra 2017
zovirax otc usa cafergot over the counter viagra comparison levitra 20mg price doxycycline buy usa where can i buy retin a cream in australia propecia online uk disulfiram tablets
gabapentin prescription cost
diflucan 50mg capsules
modafinil 2019 where can i get amoxicillin pills brand levitra online pharmacy antabuse buy uk
antabuse 500mg
tretinoin uk prescription
cost of ivermectin 3mg tablets
12.5 mg furosemide
0.125 mg synthroid
neurontin brand name
buy azithromycin online canada
order retin a without prescription endep 25 mg price amitriptyline online cafergot online pharmacy
price of zithromax
celebrex 50 mg capsules
zithromax pills online
prozac cost in canada
buy retin a medication
gabapentin cream where to buy
buy prednisone online without a script
generic propecia 5mg online
where to buy generic lexapro
cafergot internet pharmacy
diflucan order online uk
buy lyrica
cafegot
where to get zithromax over the counter
propecia coupon
buy prozac online purchase propecia no prescription amoxicillin south africa zithromax antibiotic without prescription azithromycin capsules tetracycline 250mg capsules online 1050 mg seroquel
livitra
buy metformin on line stromectol sales prednisone buy without prescription buy tetracycline uk how to get prednisone over the counter
levitra over the counter uk
doxycycline 100mg without a prescription
amoxicillin over the counter australia
synthroid canada pharmacy
strattera without prescription
azithromycin online uk
cafegot
average cost of prozac
online levitra purchase diflucan otc uk promo code for canadian pharmacy meds cost of generic lisinopril combivent aerosol antabuse online
provigil online us pharmacy
accutane medicine singapore
canadian pharmacy no prescription needed
can i buy albuterol online
amoxil 500
how much is gabapentin 300 mg tretinoin 025 online
diflucan 50mg
prednisone brand name in usa
predizone with out a percription
how to get prozac online
buy doxycycline 200 mg
foreign online pharmacy
retin a 0.5 cream uk
buy stromectol uk
antabuse otc cymbalta rx coupon buy propecia online australia generic cafergot
doxycycline 100mg price 1mg
cialis for daily use 5 mg cost
order azithromycin 500mg online buy azithromycin us can you buy metformin trazodone without prescription finasteride 1mg over the counter prednisone 5mg capsules
celebrex 200 mg coupon
buy amoxil online usa
[url=https://tadalafilm.monster/]cialis 10 price[/url] [url=https://cymbaltatab.quest/]drug cymbalta[/url] [url=https://hydroxychloroquinetabs.monster/]plaquenil sulfate[/url] [url=https://trazodonedesyrel.online/]buy trazodone online canada[/url] [url=https://augmentintabs.online/]cost of augmentin in india[/url] [url=https://propecial.online/]how to get propecia[/url] [url=https://azithromycin.run/]zithromax pack[/url] [url=https://amoxicilline.online/]buy amoxicillin 500mg online[/url]
amoxicillin price 500 mg
levitra discount canada
buy lexapro 10 mg
furosemide brand
zovirax where to buy over the counter lyrica fluoxetine hcl 20 mg capsules best price for levitra 20mg can i buy viagra otc
zovirax medication
tetracycline cheap
can i buy amoxicillin tretinoin gel plaquenil weight loss how much is the price of clomid cymbalta generic
azithromycin 250mg tablets can i order prednisone foreign online pharmacy
tetracycline cheapest price propecia 5mg sale lyrica generic south africa trazodone 250 mg
order generic viagra online
100mg sildenafil for sale
propecia 10 years
celebrex 200 mg tablets
provigil buy canada
stromectol pill for humans
levitra prices
zithromax cost in mexico tetracycline 30 where can i get azithromycin 500 mg buy cafergot pills buy generic augmentin
desyrel tablet 100 mg
cheapest amoxicillin 875
furosemide tablets australia
levitra uk
lyrica 100 mg pill
how to buy doxycycline online
cheapest prescription pharmacy
buy augmentin online europe
plaquenil brand coupon
tretinoin 0.1 buy
metformin generic price
generic azithromycin finpecia without prescription order antabuse cost of prednisolone uk desyrel tadalafil in india online azithromycin 1000 mg buy
prednisone where to buy uk
tretinoin cream buy online australia
antibiotics amoxicillin
levitra online buy
best price generic propecia
prozac tablet
modafinil pharmacy uk
purchase stromectol online lexapro generic cost can you buy propecia over the counter cafergot tablets price
buy plaquenil online uk
price of prozac in india
trazodone 100 mg
canadian pharmacy uk delivery
lisinopril 40 mg generic
zithromax medication buy amoxil 500 mg online cheap viagra canada free shipping
where can you get azithromycin over the counter
tadalafil price comparison
zoloft brand name price
diflucan uk price
lexapro 20mg tablet
online purchase of tetracycline
price of doxycycline 100mg
zovirax online
tetracycline 250 coupon
levitra usa
provigil daily use
buy viagra australia online doxycycline 100mg cost australia buy accutane online from europe lisinopril pill 40 mg finasteride generic
prednisolone 5mg for sale
rx coupon augmentin tretinoin buy online uk pink viagra for women cialis online prescription order
doxycycline 20 mg cost cafergot brand name canadian pharmacy generic tadalafil provigil 200 mg generic azithromycin 500mg purchase disulfiram 200 mg american pharmacy lyrica 10 mg
order clomid 50mg prednisone steroids mexico rx amoxicillin pharmacy online australia free shipping can i buy modafinil over the counter average cost of cialis for daily use www canadianonlinepharmacy azithromycin buy us
clomid fertility
cheap azithromycin
propecia pills
canadian pharmacy ed medications
amoxicillin 500mg capsule buy online
amoxicillin generic price
propecia 1mg tablets uk
quineprox 800 mg
stromectol 3 mg tablet price
can you buy amoxicillin otc
doxycycline medication cost
best canadian online pharmacy cialis tretinoin 5 gel
strattera drug
generic plaquenil cost lasix 40mg gabapentin 180 best online foreign pharmacy
lisinopril cost canada
lisinopril 80 mg daily
zoloft 75 mg tablet
synthroid 25 amitriptyline without prescription propecia where to buy canada amoxil price neurontin 800 mg price lisinopril 10 12.5 mg amitriptyline 10mg online buy zoloft no prescription
retin a cream generic
lasix buy online
cheap generic vardenafil
buy propecia cheap online
cafergot gabapentin 300mg online acyclovir cream for sale online buy doxycycline united states vardenafil online india
buy tetracycline 500mg ivermectin buy augmentin rx cost buy clomid canada pharmacy prozac australia prescription
amitriptyline online india
bayer levitra augmentin 375 mg price onlinepharmaciescanada provigil 200 mg generic buy clomid uk
cheap zithromax pills buy tetracycline cream prednisone 300 mg
where can i get zithromax over the counter
can you order modafinil online
1500 mg metformin
trazodone 200 azithromycin 500 buy online
cheap vardenafil 20 mg
celebrex price south africa
prozac 30 mg
buy generic lyrica
hydroxychloroquine generic name
canadian prices for sildenafil
fluoxetine online pharmacy
seroquel od
modafinil price
amitriptyline 50 cafergot australia cost of accutane 2017 generic seroquel prices antabuse prescription uk how to get propecia pharmaceutical online ordering
terramycin pfizer
buy trazodone online uk
prozac canada price
where can i get genuine viagra
ivermectin 8 mg
mexican pharmacy what to buy
terramycin ophthalmic ointment
pharmacy com
amoxicillin fast delivery acyclovir cream over the counter usa canadian pharmacy antibiotics buy antabuse without prescripition canada pharmacy lexapro
how to get levitra prescription
canada pharmacy online legit
where can i buy levitra without prescription
amoxicillin 1000 mg capsule
cafergot no prescription
zithromax 500 tablet
how to get antabuse
buy stromectol online uk
lexapro canada online pharmacy albuterol
online pharmacy no prescription needed
amitriptyline 10